Work

Phenotype Before Genotype? The Order of Cell‐Free DNA and the First‐Trimester Scan in 11,270 Pregnancies

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To examine when cell-free DNA (cfDNA) was drawn relative to the first-trimester scan, whether the phenotype redirected genetic testing, whether a positive result's meaning varied with condition and phenotype, and what order changes when the same components are used. METHODS: weeks (2009-2026); chart review of those with nuchal translucency (NT) 3.5 mm or more and cfDNA (n = 19); positive predictive value (PPV) across 1739 pregnancies with a cfDNA result. Modelled: five hypothetical pathways applied to 11,111 pregnancies. Abnormalities were known only where tested, so modelled counts are eligibility for referral and not detection rates. RESULTS: Observed: cfDNA became available in November 2015 and was used in 7.6% of the 2016-2026 cohort; 40.2% of samples preceded the scan. Of those 19 pregnancies, 16 were sampled before any phenotyping and none later; all five low-risk results were superseded. PPV fell from 95% (trisomy 21) to 17% (sex chromosome aneuploidies). Modelled: both pathways had identical eligibility by design, differing by 261 additional modelled cfDNA tests that could not alter referral. CONCLUSION: Order changed neither modelled eligibility nor assay capability, but determined whether screening information preceded the phenotype that establishes whether it is needed.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7235196997
FWCI:
Cites: 27
Cited by:
Related to: 10