Work

Diminishing Returns in PRO System: A System-Level Constraint Beyond Membrane Performance

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Pressure retarded osmosis (PRO) systems are often evaluated against the theoretical free energy of mixing available from a salinity gradient. However, the pursuit of thermodynamic completeness may underestimate an inherent physical characteristic of the dilution process: the permeate flow rate (Qp) is a monotonically decreasing hyperbolic function of the draw solution outlet concentration (Cds,out). Pushing dilution deeper leads to diminishing returns, as each additional unit of dilution requires disproportionately more membrane area while contributing progressively less energy. This work uses Qp as the connecting variable to reinterpret the established transport and mass-balance equations, and analysis how dilution influences energy recovery, membrane utilization and overall system performance. The results show that, as the Qp (dilution depth) increases, water flux approaches zero, resulting in a nonlinear decline in energy per membrane area from i.e. 100 W/m² to below 1 W/m² at an applied pressure of 10 bar. Alternatively, staging dilution at 120 bar followed by 40 bar increases energy recovery 50% without additional membrane area. This work also indicates that the membrane performance does not directly translate into system level performance. Therefore, it is proposed to consider the efficient membrane utilization and appropriate dilution depth in PRO membrane module and system design.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235197702
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10