A New Approach to the Existence of the Ultimate Necessary Foundation of Being
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This preprint examines whether ontological dependence supports the existence of a necessary foundation of being. Using conceptual analysis, classical predicate logic, and modal logic, it reconstructs the argument in two stages and makes its assumptions explicit. The first stage derives the existence of at least one non-derivative fact among the grounds of a dependent fact, conditional on domain closure, transitivity, and the well-foundedness of grounding priority. The second stage establishes the necessary obtaining of that fundamental fact by adding the principle that every obtaining contingent fact has a ground. The analysis distinguishes fundamentality from necessity, grounding from physical causation, and formal validity from the truth of metaphysical premises. The paper evaluates objections concerning the principle of sufficient reason, circularity, infinite regress, brute facts, holistic explanations, modal collapse, and the limits of metaphysical knowledge. Its conclusion is conditional: the specified premises support a necessary fundamental fact, but do not independently establish a unique necessary being, a complete explanation of all reality, or divine attributes such as consciousness, will, and benevolence. The paper clarifies the structural, modal, and theological commitments involved in moving from dependence to necessity and identifies questions requiring further argument.
Author: HAMID ZAMAN-POUR, MoHerman
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235201461
