Work

The Cost of Learning Judgment: Retrieval–Judgment Structure and Adolescent Learning Motivation in AI-Age China

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Generative artificial intelligence has driven the cost of obtaining information close to zero without lowering the cost of judging it to a comparable degree. This article separates learning cost into retrieval cost (R) and judgment cost (J) and asks why, as learning becomes cheaper, the motivation of a subset of Chinese adolescents falls. AI compresses the front end of R while the unit cost of the steps after R barely changes; the fall in J is derivative—it comes from having fewer candidates to judge, not from AI taking over judgment—and the marginal cost of J rises again once AI returns a large volume of plausible but doubtful candidates. Judgment is not internally flat: the scale of the knowledge structure that must be mobilised subsumes the distinction between lower- and higher-order judgment, so the larger the mobilisation, the dearer and the less substitutable the step. On the exchange side, motivation depends on expected return (E), the credibility of delivery (T), and perceived fairness (F), minus the two costs; T is the credibility of an intertemporal commitment and cannot be folded into E, which is a probability of obtaining. China’s high-stakes standardized assessment regime has long priced only answers that are retrievable, reproducible, and scorable, while the credential–establishment–hukou–housing–marriage composite return has depreciated amid credential inflation, contracting establishment positions, and weak signal governance; with a single evaluation scale and a mismatch in timing, withdrawal is confirmed by behaviour and closes a loop into learned helplessness. The article sets out an R–J framework and seven testable propositions; the exit threshold and the measurement of mobilisation are left as interfaces.
Author: Yilin Li
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235239076
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10