Generative AI Opinion Revision: A Unified Directional Framework for Evidence-Driven Opinion Adaptation Across Human–AI, AI–AI, and Human–Human Interactions
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The ability to revise an established opinion in response to newly acquired information is a fundamental component of adaptive intelligence, rational communication, and evidence-responsive interaction. Although existing research has investigated belief revision, language-model reasoning adaptability, social influence, opinion dynamics, and human attitude change, these research areas generally address particular forms of opinion or belief modification, specific interaction settings, or narrowly defined computational tasks. This paper proposes Generative AI Opinion Revision (GAIOR), a unified conceptual framework for understanding, structuring, and evaluating evidence-driven opinion adaptation across multiple interacting entities. The framework extends beyond the conventional treatment of opinion revision as a unilateral change within an individual system by explicitly incorporating the directionality of information exchange and revision authority among human users, generative AI systems, and multiple interacting agents. It distinguishes eight interaction configurations, encompassing unidirectional and bidirectional revision among AI systems, between humans and AI systems, among human users, and across heterogeneous multi-agent environments. Furthermore, GAIOR establishes a six-stage revision lifecycle consisting of initial opinion establishment, new information acquisition, information–opinion relationship assessment, revision necessity evaluation, adaptive opinion revision, and revised opinion validation. Seven possible revision outcomes are formalized: retention, reinforcement, weakening, refinement, modification, reversal, and withdrawal. A central theoretical distinction is introduced between undergoing a revision process and necessarily changing the final opinion: an entity may reassess its position and rationally retain it when the newly available information does not justify modification. The paper also develops a multidimensional evaluation model addressing evidence responsiveness, revision accuracy, directional consistency, unjustified revision, opinion stability, information provenance, and cross-agent revision integrity. By integrating previously fragmented perspectives into a direction-sensitive interaction architecture, this study presents, to the best of our knowledge, the first unified conceptual framework specifically organized around comprehensive opinion revision across human–AI, AI–AI, and human–human interactions, including both unidirectional and bidirectional configurations. The framework provides a theoretical foundation for future empirical research, benchmark development, adaptive conversational systems, and evidence-grounded multi-agent architectures.
Author: Zhang, Jincheng
Language: English
Subfield: Statistical and Nonlinear Physics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235239923
