Tier Four: Constitutional Non-Compliance
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: In April 2019, the Ninth Circuit upheld California's California Values Act against the federal government's challenge in United States v. California, ruling unanimously that state law enforcement officers cannot be required to assist federal immigration enforcement, that the state's prohibition on local and state cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement operated within the Tenth Amendment's anti-commandeering reservation, and that "[r]efusing to help is not the same as impeding." The opinion is the contemporary articulation of Tier Four. State governmental actors hold constitutional authority to refuse cooperation with federal commands that exceed federal constitutional authority and to obstruct, through facially neutral statutes operating within state jurisdiction, the operation of those commands. The authority is grounded in anti-commandeering doctrine, the McCulloch v. Maryland valid-exercise principle, and Article VI clause 3's binding of state officials to the Constitution itself rather than to the federal apparatus's interpretation of it. Tier Four is the architectural category in which state sovereignty operates as a structural check on federal action that the federal apparatus cannot enforce by the means available to it under the constitutional text. Author: Christopher Armitage, christopherarmitage.com. Publisher: The Existentialist Republic, theexistentialistrepublic.com. Gavel Grab, gavelgrab.org.
Author: Armitage, Christopher
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235272572
