Work

Lifespan Mental Health in Alberta: COVID-19 Effects on Service Utilization, Geographic Inequities and Implications for Training

Year: 2026
Type: other
Abstract: Background: Rural and remote populations in Canada face unique mental health challenges exacerbated by socioeconomic disparities, systemic barriers to care, and scarcity of specialized services. The COVID-19 pandemic further strained healthcare delivery systems, potentially widening existing inequities. This dissertation investigates the landscape of rural psychiatric illness in Canada, focusing on pandemic impacts in Alberta, examining longitudinal trends in service utilization across the lifespan and evaluating educational interventions designed to strengthen the rural psychiatric workforce.Methods: This research employed a multi-modal approach comprising nine interrelated studies. Study 1 consisted of a narrative review and synthesis of literature on non-psychotic psychiatric illness in rural Canada from 2001-2023 to map the prevalence of non-psychotic psychiatric conditions and risk factors specific to rural Canada. Studies 2 through 7 leveraged large-scale administrative physician billing data (representing over 12.7 million encounters from 2017-2022). Using a retrospective longitudinal, cohort design, these studies applied one-way ANOVAs, generalized linear models (GLM), and regression analyses to quantify shifts in psychiatric presentations. Data were stratified by pandemic phase (pre-, pandemic, post-pandemic), developmental stage (children/adolescents, emerging adults, adults, and older adults), biological sex, and geographic location (urban vs. rural) to identify disparities in healthcare settings (outpatient vs. emergency vs. inpatient). Finally, Studies 8 and 9 employed survey methodology and qualitative analysis to assess psychiatry residents' interest in rural practice and the impact of an enriched rural psychiatry curriculum at the University of Alberta.Results: The narrative review (Study 1) established elevated rates of depression, anxiety, and suicidality in rural areas and identified fragmented service delivery as a contributing factor, emphasizing the need for innovative, community-based interventions. The population-based analyses (Studies 2-7) revealed that the pandemic’s impact varied by demographic, with different consistent trends emerging. Among children and adolescents (6-17 years), overall presentations increased during the pandemic, followed by a surge in outpatient presentations post-pandemic, with adolescents showing the highest rates of presentations, and females showing the highest rates of anxiety, mood, and eating disorder and non-suicidal self-injury presentations. Emerging adults (18-24 years) demonstrated a "crisis-first" utilization pattern in rural areas, relying heavily on EDs for substance use and non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI). In the adult population (25-64 years), while total presentations remained stable, diagnosis-specific shifts occurred: anxiety and personality disorders increased during the pandemic, while eating disorders and substance use disorders showed a significant "rebound" in acuity post-pandemic. Older adults (65+ years) saw a notable increase in presentations during the pandemic, primarily driven by outpatient anxiety and mood disorder visits that stabilized and remained elevated post-pandemic. Across all age groups, a persistent geographic divide was identified: urban residents predominantly utilized outpatient services, whereas rural residents were significantly more likely to access psychiatric care through emergency departments and inpatient settings. This "rural gap" suggests a systemic lack of community-based infrastructure. Regarding workforce development, the educational studies (Studies 8-9) identified interest in learning about rural and remote mental health needs, with a small percentage of residents who experienced an enriched rural curriculum intending to relocate to practice in rural areas full-time (17.6%), primarily mature residents with substantial prior rural exposure. However, 88.2% were interested in "hybrid" models like telepsychiatry and outreach. Thematic analysis showed that although the enriched curriculum improved perceived cultural competence and preparedness, significant logistical issues (e.g., housing, transportation, financial considerations) remained barriers to rural recruitment.Conclusions: This dissertation reveals a psychiatric system in transition, where the COVID-19 pandemic acted as a disruptor that entrenched a "crisis-first" model of rural care that is both clinically insufficient and economically unsustainable. To achieve health equity, the research advocates for a multi-pronged strategy: 1) enhancing workforce capacity by embedding rurality as a structural determinant of health in medical curricula to shift the workforce trajectory from urban-centric to equity-oriented; 2) adopting "technologically-tethered" clinical practice models that utilize hybrid outreach and telepsychiatry to ensure continuity of care; and 3) implementing systemic policy reorganization under initiatives like Recovery Alberta to prioritize outpatient stability over emergency intervention. Ultimately, dismantling geographic barriers requires robust digital infrastructure and community-centred approaches, flexible training pathways, and a focused commitment to the 19% of the population living beyond the province's urban centres.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235384641
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10