Work

Comparative Validation of Karate Kumite Performance Profiles Using Multiple Clustering Methods

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study examines when clusters derived from karate kumite match data are sufficiently corroborated to be interpreted as athlete-performance profiles.Data comprised 114 athlete-match observations from 57 female WKF matches.Rather than relying on cluster separation (silhouette) from a single algorithm, as commonly reported, five algorithms with differing assumptions (Ward, k-Means, DBSCAN, RSKC-STOF, ARSK) clustered the data using outcome-independent features.These clusters were considered corroborated only if consistent across algorithms, stronger than a permutation null, not representation artifacts, and reproducible under match and athlete resampling with model re-selection.Methodologically, comparison across algorithms, representation analysis, and repeated model selection each demonstrated the insufficiency of cluster separation from a single algorithm.All silhouettes were weak (0.31-0.49), and comparing algorithms showed the five Female-47 kg clusters from k-Means alone disagreed with other algorithms (ARI = 0.24-0.58),indicating algorithm-dependent clusters; representation analysis showed the Female-54 kg partition, though algorithm-independent, merely separated scorers from non-scorers (ARI = 1.0), indicating a representation artifact; and repeated model selection showed the Female-42 kg four-cluster solution recurred in 29-38% of resamples, leaving the cluster number uncertain.For karate performance analysis, the clusters mostly reflected scoring rather than fighting behavior: attack and defend did not differ between Female-54 kg or main Female-42 kg clusters (overlapping 95% CIs).For the present data, only Female-42 kg contained partially corroborated profiles, non-scorers (n = 14) and high-yuko scorers (n = 15; yuko = 4.67), whereas Female-47 kg was not corroborated and Female-54 kg was reproducible but not corroborated.
Language: English
Subfield: Safety Research
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7235444912
FWCI:
Cites: 29
Cited by:
Related to: 10