Work

Epistemological and Practical Limitations of Evidence-Based Urban Development

Year: 2026
Type: report
Abstract: Urban science can clarify development problems through observation, causal inquiry, comparative evaluation, and public scrutiny. The use of its findings for intervention also requires justification of their applicability to changing conditions, the values guiding action, and the authority through which a decision is made. This conceptual paper examines these requirements across epistemology, ontology, complex-system dynamics, normativity, governance, and jurisprudence. Its multilevel taxonomy distinguishes evidential validity, correspondence to an intervention’s target, the limits of representations of human experience, dynamical risks, normative objectives, public answerability, and legal attribution. A conditional formal account of generative transformation clarifies selected structural distinctions without establishing empirical urban mechanisms or duties. The paper then identifies methodological precautions and possible safeguards concerning provenance, causal assumptions, changing system conditions, participation, contestation, and review. These proposals are intended for comparison with existing urban planning and evaluation arrangements. Their causal effectiveness and administrative costs have not been established, and jurisdiction-specific obligations cannot be inferred from the conceptual framework alone.
Language: English
Subfield: Urban Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235503718
Cites: 44
Cited by:
Related to: 10