Work

What Does the Environmental Phillips Curve Measure? Okun’s Law, Trends and Cyclical Emissions in the G7, 1975–2024

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The Environmental Phillips Curve (EPC) posits a trade-off between unemployment and environmental pressure. This paper asks what the EPC measures once trends are removed and Okun’s law is taken into account. Using G7 data for 1975–2024, we recast the EPC as a chain linking Okun’s law and the cyclical emissions–output relationship, estimate every link in levels and in deviations from trend with fixed-effects, mean-group, common-correlated-effects, panel ARDL (pooled mean group) and CS-ARDL estimators, and test the restriction implied by Okun’s law with a joint moving-block bootstrap. In deviations from trend, unemployment 10% above trend is associated with CO₂ emissions per capita 1.1% below trend. Okun’s law and the emissions–output elasticity account for 83% of this relationship with fixed effects, with a 95% bootstrap interval of 0.62–0.98, and for all of it with the mean-group estimator. The relationship is essentially contemporaneous and robust to the HP, Hamilton and boosted HP filters and to the sample period: across four filters and three periods, the fixed-effects EPC ranges from − 0.115 to − 0.072 and Okun’s law accounts for 83–108% of it. In levels, the EPC is fragile, sensitive to the sample window and absent from both PMG and CS-ARDL estimates in every period. The EPC is therefore best understood as the environmental image of Okun’s law, and cyclical emission reductions should not be counted as progress towards decarbonisation targets. JEL classification: Q43; Q54; Q56; E24; E32; C22; C23
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235567331
Cites: 54
Cited by:
Related to: 10