Comprehensive Assessment of the Effectiveness of Existing Risk Management Tools at Agricultural Enterprises
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The article presents a theoretical and methodological substantiation. It develops a multi-tiered framework for evaluating the effectiveness of risk management tools in agricultural enterprises facing a confluence of climatic, market, institutional, and war-induced shocks. It is evident that the open, bio-ecological nature of agricultural production necessitates a shift from reactive ex-post damage control to an integrated Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) framework grounded in system resilience (robustness, adaptability, and transformability). The study decomposes primary agricultural risk vectors and their underlying triggers. A comparative analysis of risk transfer, mitigation, and retention mechanisms (multi-peril crop insurance [MPCI], index-based weather insurance, forward contracts, exchange-traded Put options, crop diversification, and internal financial buffers) is conducted to identify their inherent operational trade-offs and basis risks. A quantitative methodology for evaluating risk management efficacy is formalized, replacing traditional variance metrics with asymmetric tail-risk measures ( — , — ) and von Neumann–Morgenstern Expected Utility Theory via the Certainty Equivalent ( ). The marginal capital protection efficiency ratio ( ) and an integrated performance index ( ) are introduced to weigh tail-risk reduction against direct, transaction, and opportunity costs. Furthermore, the war-driven adaptation of Ukrainian agricultural risk management is analyzed, highlighting decentralized grain storage in polymer sleeves (silobags), GIS and drone monitoring, conservation tillage (No-Till/Strip-Till), the "5-7-9%" subsidized credit program, and maritime war-risk insurance pools. Finally, a multi-level strategy to optimize risk management practices at the micro, meso, and macro levels is formulated.
Author: V. Verbovyi
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Zero hunger
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7235589689
