A Study on the Imbalanced Application of "Moral Sanctions" and "Legal Sanctions" in Juvenile School Bullying
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: China's legal norms including the Minor Protection Law and the Law on the Prevention of Juvenile Delinquency have established a legal framework for governing school bullying. A tiered disposal mechanism has been set up for school bullying of varying severity, covering relatively flexible educational measures as well as rigid legal sanctions. Nevertheless, in real-world school governance practices, numerous malignant school bullying cases that meet the criteria for legal sanctions end with moral and social disciplinary measures such as critical education, written self-criticisms and apologies. Legal sanctions remain largely idle and nominal, giving rise to the application imbalance characterised by "over-reliance on moral sanctions and absence of legal sanctions". This imbalance does not stem from deficient legislation but cognitive deviations at the societal-perception level: the general public, school administrators and some parents misinterpret the juvenile-justice principle of "education first, punishment supplementary", equating the protection of minors with unrestrained tolerance for perpetrators. Coupled with schools' stability-maintenance inclination and victims' insufficient willingness to safeguard their rights, social perceptions override legal norms in practice and prevent legal provisions from translating into real-world binding force. Starting with conceptual definition, this paper sorts out the proper applicable boundaries of moral sanctions and legal sanctions, illustrates practical manifestations of disciplinary imbalance, explores the internal mechanism whereby social perceptions override the law, assesses multiple hazards brought by such imbalance, and puts forward optimisation proposals including reshaping public perceptions and clarifying disciplinary hierarchies. It expects to realise the coordinated operation of moral education and legal sanctions in school-bullying governance.
Author: Yinyin Zhang
Language: English
Topic: Legal Issues in Education
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7235599654
