Why Can't a Stone Turn into Gold: Material Thinking vs Structural Thinking — A Shenkexue Paper
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: English version of the Chinese paper 《石头为什么不能变金子》 (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24046301). Why can't a stone turn into gold? In material thinking there is nothing to ask — a stone is a stone and gold is gold, two materials that never cross. But in structural thinking, a stone and gold share one bottom layer (quarks) arranged in two ways; change the arrangement and the stone becomes gold. This single difference is the watershed between material thinking and structural thinking: material thinking locks change inside time (so instantaneous change is superstition), while structural thinking sees that change is only the flowing of structure (so instantaneous change is only a rearrangement). Three images — the magic brush of Ma Liang, the Transformers, turning stone into gold — are one and the same thing. Three old discoveries (nuclear transmutation, Mendeleev's periodic table, the three forms of carbon) are three faces of the same fact: arrangement decides everything. A thought experiment — a world without time can be imagined and believed; a world without structure can be pictured but not believed — shows time is a property while structure is existence. The paper honestly declares it does not claim to prove, only asks the reader to compare.
Author: Lin, Xiaohei
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235651568
