Work

The progressive left in England: a multi-dimensional values approach to multiculturalism and national belonging

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Despite widespread recognition that unidimensional left-right scales inadequately identify post-industrial political cleavages, the sociological architecture of the English left remains under-theorised, frequently reduced to reactive opposition or elite capture. This paper constructs a multi-dimensional Progressive Left index – operationalising welfare statism, gender equality, and labour solidarity – to examine how egalitarian values shape defences of multiculturalism. Analysis of a nationally representative survey from May 2025 (English subsample N = 1,851; analytic N = 1,587) via hierarchical logistic regression indicates that these three pillars are the strongest observed predictors of non-endorsement of exclusionary nationalist narratives, particularly regarding minority faiths. The findings complicate the influential Brahmin Left thesis: the association between higher education and cultural tolerance is substantially attenuated once progressive values are accounted for, with non-graduate leftists defending pluralism as forcefully as their graduate counterparts when holding equivalent ideological commitments. Intersectional analysis further suggests that socio-demographic position, specifically ethnic minority status and younger cohorts, is independently associated with multicultural defence, distinctly from measured values. These results are consistent with an account of the present-day English left as a values-based formation wherein commitments to material fairness and cultural pluralism operate as closely related dimensions of a broadly shared democratic worldview, rather than competing priorities of a fragmented demographic coalition.
Author: Tahir Abbas
Institution: Aston University
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,990
OpenAlex ID: W7235652874
FWCI:
Cites: 56
Cited by:
Related to: 10