Quasistable multiclonal carcinomas evolve through mutations with locally extended phenotypes
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The earliest stages of epithelial carcinogenesis are often considered to arise via lineal evolution, a mutation-driven process characterised by purely competitive clonal interactions. However, this conventional view cannot fully explain the persistent polyclonality observed in many cancers. We therefore investigated an alternative mechanism of cancer progression, termed interclonal cooperation, arising from mutations that cause cells to produce microenvironmental changes, enabling them to affect the behaviours of surrounding cells. We built a Voronoi cell-based model (VCBM) of epithelial carcinogenesis evolution to examine the role of cancer cell interactions in proliferation, motility and degradation of the extracellular matrix (ECM) during the earliest stages of carcinogenesis. In this model, we considered mutations with four distinct effects on cells: impaired apoptosis, faster cell-cycling, hyperproliferation and enhanced invasiveness. In each case, these phenotypes can be either cell-autonomous, affecting only the mutated cell itself, or microenvironmental, affecting both the mutated cell and the surrounding cells within a specified range. Using our model, we investigated how microenvironmentally extended phenotypes in epithelial cells influence the formation of carcinogenic lesions. We found that the acquisition of microenvironmentally extended phenotypes reduces the overall mutational burden of the tissue by increasing the competitiveness of non-mutant cells with cells harbouring cell-autonomous mutations. However, progression from pre-malignancy to malignancy can occur without the acquisition of additional mutations, through field collision, i.e. by the growth and/or migration of mutually beneficial clones, leading to their co-localisation, which enables malignant interactions. Our results also indicate that mutations with microenvironmentally extended phenotypes can enhance the speed with which malignancy occurs compared with cell-autonomous phenotypes, through symbiotic clonal interactions. An important contribution to the speed of carcinogenesis is the ability of microenvironmentally extended phenotypes to overcome mutual inhibition of pro-malignant intracellular signalling pathways. Moreover, we found that, after an initial period of rapid change and clonal succession during carcinogenesis, genetically distinct clones of cell types persist together for long periods, maintaining stable proportions. Author summary Cancer progression is regulated not only by genetic mutations within individual cells, but also by interactions between genetically different cancer cell populations. Many models of cancer focus on competitive single-cell behaviour, whereas few studies have investigated how cooperative interactions among cancer cell clones can affect the early stages of carcinogenesis. To this end, we developed a computational model to investigate how cooperative cell-cell interactions influence the malignant behaviour of cells during the early stages of epithelial carcinogenesis. Our results show that cooperative cell populations can become malignant faster than non-cooperative cells, especially in cases where oncogenic signalling pathways are mutually incompatible within individual cells, and result in persistent clonal heterogeneity within the malignant lesion. These findings highlight the importance of cell-cell interactions in the early stages of tumour growth that progress to cancer and demonstrate how mathematical modelling can provide insight into the complex evolutionary processes of cancer, which are challenging to observe experimentally.
Institutions: The University of Sydney, Centenary Institute
Language: English
Subfield: Modeling and Simulation
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235671996
