Work

Assessing Sustainable Competitive-Advantage Potential in Energy Service Companies: A Capability-Based Framework Under Energy Performance Contracting

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Energy service companies (ESCOs) are central to energy performance contracting (EPC), yet firm-level differences in competitive capacity remain less studied than market barriers, contracts, and policy. This study develops a capability-based framework for assessing sustainable competitive-advantage potential by distinguishing Current Market Performance (CMP), Organizational Capability Base (OCB), and Future Adaptive Capacity (FAC). Three ESCOs are evaluated using 2024 firm-level empirical data across 25 indicators. Fifteen experts completed the AHP weighting exercise, and seven core experts from the same panel also scored the qualitative indicators. AHP provides the decision-weight structure, a multi-level fuzzy model provides the baseline assessment, and TOPSIS plus structural and parameter sensitivity tests examine how rankings respond to alternative modelling assumptions. The elicited AHP structure assigns 62.5% of total priority to OCB, with access to financing receiving the largest global indicator weight; these values are interpreted as expert decision priorities rather than causal effects. Both aggregation methods rank Firm C first, followed by B and A. Firm C remains first across 12 first-level weight perturbations and alternative debt-ratio and quick-ratio targets. Firms A and B exchange ranks when the OCB weight rises to approximately 0.672 and when project profitability and bid-success rate are reassigned to Current Market Performance. The results therefore support a comparatively stable leading position for Firm C under the tested assumptions, while showing that lower ranks are sensitive to modelling choices. The framework is intended as a cross-sectional capability diagnostic for competitive-advantage potential in the 2024 assessment period rather than being proof of persistent advantage over time.
Source: Energies
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,137
OpenAlex ID: W7235677829
FWCI:
Cites: 63
Cited by:
Related to: 10