Work

Ferdinand Tönnies and the Sociological Roots of Dual-Process Theories of Thinking: Cognition, Social Relations, and Modernity

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Dual-process theories of thinking occupy an important place in contemporary psychology, economics, and cognitive sociology. They distinguish intuitive activities, often rapid and involving little deliberation, from more controlled and reflective activities. Similar distinctions were already present in classical psychology and sociology. This article revisits that intellectual history through Ferdinand Tönnies, who distinguishes organic will (Wesenwille) from rational will (Kürwille) and relates them to communal and societal relations. We show how this theory corresponds to contemporary research and how its ambition to explain psychological activities and social forms together can enrich that research. We then discuss three limitations of certain historical interpretations offered by Tönnies: the naturalisation of differences between the sexes, the association of reflection with modernity, and the association of calculation with market relations. This discussion leads us to examine modernity as a transformation of the social conditions under which intuitive and reflective activities develop and are exercised. To this end, we propose four complementary dimensions: the cultivation, mobilisation, social distribution, and sociotechnical delegation of cognitive activities. The framework examines how institutions shape cognitive learning, judgement, and recognition, while the activities thereby organised contribute in turn to the reproduction and transformation of the social relations within which they occur.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235691552
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10