The Logvinovich Dichotomy on ℝ⁴: Class-Relative Negative Resolution, Burden Calibration, the Sharp Positivity Theorem for the Gribov–Zwanziger Instrument Family, the Audit of Eight Attempted Closures of the Upper Exit, and the Conditional Inevitability Theorem (Audited Edition v21)
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: We prove a class-relative negative resolution of the canonical constructive Yang–Mills mass-gap formulation on ℝ⁴, together with an exact calibration of what such a result can and cannot deliver. Inside the declared canonical class C⁻(ℝ⁴) := {M : H1 ∧ H2⁻} (formalized in both conjunctive and literal disjunctive forms), the Osterwalder–Schrader / Wightman package and a strict spectral mass gap Δ > 0 are mutually exclusive, and the five-part non-vacuity and conjunct-separation certificate holds. We do not construct a Yang–Mills measure on ℝ⁴, we do not claim the Clay Millennium Prize, and we do not claim ¬Clay for the physical theory. Principal Results in Audited Edition v21: 1. Eight Named Class-Free Theorems and Five Class-Free Propositions (Independent of H1 and H2⁻):• Peano–Archimedes No-Gap & Reciprocal-Tail Expulsion: Any operator retaining the reciprocal infrared tail E(λ) = (λ + 1)⁻¹ has Δ = 0; conversely, any rational lower bound Δ = (p + 1)/(q + 1) > 0 expels the entire tail (q + 2 + k)⁻¹ for all k ∈ ℕ, and any positive rational lower bound (HasPositiveRationalGap) closes irrational spectral gaps such as Δ = √2 (witnessed by the Pell sequence E_n = p_n/q_n = 3/2, 17/12, 99/70, … ↓ √2).• Sharp Positivity Criterion for the Refined Gribov–Zwanziger (RGZ) Family: For D_RGZ(p²) = (p² + M²)/(p⁴ + (M² + m²)p² + λ⁴), reflection positivity holds iff ρ ≥ 0 ⇔ OS2 ⇔ W0 ⇔ M²m² ≥ λ⁴. Under the physical RGZ horizon parametrisation λ⁴ = M²m² + 2Ng²γ⁴, positivity forces γ = 0; every γ ≠ 0 violates reflection positivity, and no rational truncation is simultaneously reflection-positive and free of positive-metric asymptotic quanta.• Gauge-Invariant Topological Susceptibility (χ_t > 0): Contact terms supported at {0} contribute identically zero to OS2 on {x₄ ≥ ε > 0}; an explicit Gaussian white-noise family realizes OS2 ∧ W0 ∧ (Δ = m > 0) ∧ (χ_t > 0).• Operator Dimension & Beta-Sign Discriminator: A dimension-four composite :φ_m⁴: in a free gapped 4D scalar theory reproduces the |x|⁻⁸ singularity and a⁻⁴ quartic divergence while all OS/Wightman axioms and Δ = m > 0 hold. Criticality (d = 4, [g] = 0) is shared by φ⁴₄ and Yang–Mills, whereas the sign of β discriminates: φ⁴₄ triviality requires β > 0, while Yang–Mills has β < 0 (as noted in Jaffe–Witten 2000), and the 2D Gross–Neveu model ([g] = 0, β < 0) is a rigorous asymptotically free gapped theory. 2. The Logvinovich Dichotomy (D1–D5), Burden Calibration & Three Legitimate Positions:• Proving the completeness bridge (Bridge := ∀M, Clay(M) ⇒ M ∈ C⁻(ℝ⁴)) is logically equivalent to proving the absolute negative solution ¬∃M, Clay(M). In the audited ontology, both ¬Bridge (D4) and ∃M, Clay(M) (D5, witnessed by the truth-value surrogate UnconstrainedCompatibleModel) are machine-checked.• Three Legitimate Referee Positions: (A) accept the reduction inside C⁻(ℝ⁴); (B) produce a finite Exit Certificate, which solves Clay positively and refutes H1, H2⁻, and Bridge; or (C) reject a named premise (H1, H2⁻, or A7). Only demanding a positive witness inside the excluded class is a formal category error. 3. Audit of Eight Attempted Closures of the Upper Exit (Clay ⇒ C⁻(ℝ⁴)):• Three sign-inverted existence theorems: trace anomaly (generates Λ_RG and blocks the dilation proof of H1), topological susceptibility χ_t > 0 (carried by an OS2-invisible contact term), and Buchholz–Fredenhagen BF82 (assumes Δ > 0 and derives cone localisation).• Two counterexample refutations: |x|⁻⁸ / χ_t non-integrability (reproduced by :φ_m⁴: in free gapped 4D scalar theory; χ_tξ² diverges in gapped 2D O(3) and is finite in 4D SU(3)) and Z_N one-form symmetry vs. asymptotic freedom (spectral gap ≠ area law; bare g₀ → 0 is UV; Balaban and Tomboulis point toward confinement).• Three regulator-removal audits: φ⁴₄ triviality dichotomy (beta-sign error + third branch along a fixed RP lattice action), order of limits a → 0, L → ∞ (restates the open Clay problem), and the covariant Dirac probe D_A (category error: D_A is a background probe, not the field-theory Hamiltonian H; free massive Dirac field is a counterexample). 4. Conditional Inevitability Theorem, No Free Reformulation & Kernel Self-Audit (C1–C7):• Under the declared consensus hypothesis P (∃M, Clay(M)), ¬Bridge holds and no sound argument whatsoever can close the upper exit, upgrading the sign-inversion ledger from an observation to a conditional theorem.• Any predicate Φ equivalent to Clay is exactly as hard as Clay, and Osterwalder–Schrader reconstruction runs one-way from the Euclidean measure to the spatial-slice Hamiltonian H (attacking the 3D slice attacks the output, never easier than the input).• Full Lean 4 kernel self-audit documenting packaging defects C1–C7, disjunctive H2⁻ closure, and finite-rank Schur/Sonin comparison (Andrews–Connes–La Gatta 2026). Files Included in This Deposit:• Logvinovich_v21.pdf — Complete 44-page audited monograph (Audited Edition v21).• Logvinovich_v21.tex — Reproducible LaTeX source of the monograph.• RoundSquare_v21.lean — Constructive Lean 4 formalization (44 Sections, 187 #print axioms checks): Sections 1–34 CI-confirmed with 0 sorry and 0 custom axioms; Blocks A–B (§35–36) locally kernel-confirmed on Lean v4.36.0-rc2; Blocks C–J (§37–44) sorry-free candidate modules. GitHub Repository & CI Verification: https://github.com/Dr-Logvinovich/round-squareCompanion Compact-Manifold Preprint (YM_V5, M_tot = S⁴ × T³): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22674891
Author: Logvinovich Victor
Institution: Brest State A.S. Pushkin University
Language: English
Subfield: Nuclear and High Energy Physics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235758464
