Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Research on losers’ consent asks whether citizens’ own party won. In ethnically divided party systems, winning and losing are also shared within groups. Does a group’s position relative to the party in power shape how its members judge democracy, even when they have no party ties of their own? I measure ethnic groups’ attachment to governing parties in 174 Afrobarometer surveys from 35 African countries and follow the same groups over time. Members of more aligned groups are more satisfied with democracy and trust electoral commissions more. The relationship is strongest among the half of respondents with no party attachment, whom standard winner–loser measures miss. It holds net of coethnicity with the president and formal inclusion in power, and it survives comparisons within regions and group-specific time trends. After turnovers, groups that gain alignment trust the electoral commission more, while groups tied to a losing challenger do not gain. Alignment is linked to perceptions and to trust in incumbent-linked institutions, not to measured local services or support for democracy as a form of government. The causal evidence is suggestive rather than conclusive. Winning and losing have a collective side: who counts as a winner depends on where one’s group stands, not only on one’s own vote.
Source: Research Square
Author: Ahmed Hamza
Institution: University of North Texas
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235781769
