The Identity Gap in Management: Why Leadership Training Does Not Change Managerial Behaviour
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Leadership training can improve knowledge and workplace performance, yet the translation of newly acquired skills into sustained managerial conduct remains variable. This paper asks why, in some cases, a manager understands and can demonstrate a leadership behaviour but does not enact it consistently in real work. It develops an integrative conceptual account that combines evidence on leadership-training effectiveness and transfer with leader-identity research and the Internal Autobiographical Map (IAM) developed by Stoyana Natseva. IAM’s five structural components—Core Experience, Conclusion, Rule, Role and Scenario—are examined as a possible reflective vocabulary for interpreting repeated managerial responses, not as an empirically confirmed causal sequence or diagnostic instrument. The article defines an “identity gap” narrowly: a persistent discrepancy between demonstrated capability and repeated enactment in relevant opportunities, after organisational, skill, planning, habit and motivational explanations have been assessed. Its original contribution is the conditional Identity–Action Translation Framework, a sequence of five evidential gates that separately establish capability, real opportunity, enactment or non-enactment across eligible occasions, the identity relevance of the behaviour, and persistence over time. The order of the gates is an order of analysis rather than of data collection: identity measures are always collected before the outcomes they predict, at baseline for most propositions and, for maintenance, after initial enactment but before a documented disruption. Four falsifiable propositions distinguish identity-related predictions from established transfer, habit and implementation-planning accounts, and a prospective mixed-method design is specified with independent behavioural ratings, measured opportunity, nested predictive models and an optional randomised phase. No new data were collected, and the framework is not claimed to validate IAM or to show that identity work improves leadership training. Leadership training can be effective; when its gains do not persist, identity-related interpretations are one testable explanation among several.
Author: Lyubomir Troharov
Language: English
Subfield: Applied Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7235793469
