Work

Effects of Novel Antimicrobial Interventions Against Clostridium estertheticum Spores: from Suspension Inactivation to Meat Shelf-life Control

Year: 2026
Type: other
Abstract: Blown pack spoilage (BPS) of vacuum-packaged beef, primarily caused by the psychrotrophic spore-forming bacterium Clostridium estertheticum, represents a major challenge to the meat industry due to economic losses and reduced product shelf-life. This study evaluated the efficacy of novel oxidative antimicrobial interventions, including ozone nanobubble solution (ONB), plasma-activated water (PAW), in comparison with conventional sanitizer peroxyacetic acid (PAA), for controlling C. estertheticum spores under suspension and meat application systems, and for assessing their subsequent effects on shelf-life, microbial dynamics, and quality of vacuum-packaged beef stored at 4°C. In the suspension study, spore inactivation was significantly influenced by treatment type, contact time, and matrix. PAA demonstrated the greatest sporicidal activity, achieving approximately 2 log CFU/mL reduction in water after 10 min, whereas ONB and PAW showed minimal activity, remaining below 0.5 log CFU/mL reduction. In the meat immersion study, ONB exhibited the greatest reduction on inoculated meat surfaces, reaching approximately 1 log reduction after 10 min, followed by PAA (~0.7 log), while PAW showed little antimicrobial effect beyond the physical washing effect of water. These findings demonstrate that treatment efficacy was strongly dependent on the surrounding matrix and mode of application. During the six-week shelf-life study, qPCR-estimated C. estertheticum populations increased rapidly between week 0 and 2 (approximately 2-3 log cells/cm2) and subsequently reached a plateau across all treatments. Significant treatment-versus-positive-control reductions in qPCR-estimated cell numbers occurred at selected conditions, most notably in PAA-treated fat samples at W2; however, these effects were not consistently sustained through storage. For TAC, selected treatment-control differences were identified using robust inference, but these effects were isolated and did not demonstrate sustained suppression of broader aerobic microbial growth. Storage progression was the most consistent driver of spoilage progression and microbial succession, while meat type influenced several outcomes, including pH, total aerobic counts, and sensory deterioration. Fat samples generally showed higher pH, greater total aerobic counts, and greater variability in lipid oxidation than lean samples, suggesting that tissue type influenced microbial proliferation and treatment response. Treatment-related pH differences relative to the positive control were condition-specific and were not consistently stable across sensitivity analyses. Microbial community analysis using 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing showed that storage week was the dominant driver of overall community structure. Shannon diversity varied with treatment group, storage week, and meat type; however, no individual antimicrobial treatment differed significantly from the positive control within a specific storage week and meat type after adjustment. Beta-diversity analysis identified a smaller overall treatment-group effect, and PAA-treated samples differed from the positive control at W2; however, this difference was not sustained at later storage weeks. Microbial communities ultimately converged toward dominance by Clostridium during storage. Lipid oxidation remained low overall, with TBARS values below 1 mg MDA/kg meat across all treatments and storage times, indicating that oxidative deterioration was limited under vacuum-packaged storage. Overall, these findings demonstrate that although oxidative antimicrobial interventions can achieve limited C. estertheticum spore inactivation under controlled conditions, their effectiveness is substantially reduced in meat systems. Shelf-life and spoilage progression in vacuum-packaged beef were governed primarily by storage time, meat type, and microbial dynamics rather than by antimicrobial treatment alone. These results highlight the need for optimized multi-hurdle strategies to control spore-forming spoilage organisms without compromising product quality.
Author: Sun,Xintong
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235798215
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10