Assessing Decision-Making Accuracy, Error Rates, and Guessing Propensity Under Dietary Caffeine Doses: A Within-Subject Pilot Investigation
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Introduction: Mental health includes how people think and make judgements, not only the absence of illness. Caffeine is believed to leave drinkers "on edge" and quick to act before thinking, yet whether everyday doses make decisions hasty or error-prone has rarely been tested. Methods Nine enrolments of eight young adults each completed three single-blind sessions in counterbalanced order, drinking placebo, 70 mg or 140 mg of caffeine (0.02 to 2.98 mg/kg). Flanker, visual short-term memory and serial-subtraction tasks and mood ratings were completed before and 5, 30 and 55 min after the drink, with skin conductance and heart rate recorded. Errors, guessing, response bias and time spent checking answers were compared with placebo, adjusting for each session's pre-dose score. Equivalence tests asked whether a rash effect of half a standard deviation could be ruled out. Results Very fast responses were rare (11 of 4,559 under 300 ms). After the drink, flanker error rates were 1.6% with placebo, 0.8% with 70 mg and 0.7% with 140 mg. At both doses, a rise of the predefined size in flanker or arithmetic errors, or a shift towards guessing on the memory task, was ruled out (p ≤ 0.035). Errors were not fast guesses, and answer checking did not decline. Jitteriness, anxiety and stress did not rise significantly, and feeling jittery was unrelated to how participants responded. Conclusion At everyday doses, caffeine did not make decisions more hasty or error-prone. Feeling on edge and acting rashly appeared to be separate.
Source: Research Square
Institution: University of Technology Malaysia
Language: English
Topic: Coffee research and impacts
Subfield: Pharmacology (medical)
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235856895
