Work

Chemical Filtering of Thymine over Uracil by Differential Hydrolysis under Dark Alkaline Hydrothermal-Vent Conditions: A Mass-Consistent, Control-Restrained Simulation Framework (UPDSF v6.7.0)

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A central question in prebiotic chemistry is why modern DNA contains thymine (5-methyluracil) rather than uracil. Most proposed answers invoke surface UV photochemistry, yet alkaline hydrothermal vents—a leading candidate cradle for prebiotic synthesis—are dark environments. Here we present UPDSF v6.7.0, a mass-consistent, kinetically-consistent, provenance-tracked simulation framework that tests whether differential hydrolysis stability alone can chemically filter thymine over uracil in dark, alkaline, high-temperature conditions. At the model optimum (90 °C, in-situ pH 11, 240 h, zero photon flux), differential hydrolysis with an Arrhenius-extrapolated rate ratio k_U/k_T ≈ 357 raises the DNA T/(U+T) fraction from below the feedstock level under a no-selection control (0.67× influx, i.e. net T depletion) to 2.02× influx in the baseline—a controlcorrected enrichment of ≈ 3.0× that is immune to the assumed influx stoichiometry and to the CSI normalization convention, because both arms of the decisive sweep share every assumption. A preregistered decisive control sweep (7 arms × 20 seeds) refutes any single-channel explanation: suppressing the polymer-side or the free-monomer-side hydrolysis differential alone collapses part of the enrichment (CSI 3.47 → 2.83 and 2.46 respectively), while suppressing both eliminates it (CSI 1.80)—chemical T-over-U filtering acts at both the monomer and polymer levels, with the 2 free-monomer channel dominant under the assumed free-hydrolysis scale. An opt-in sequenceresolved Darwinian layer (100-residue copolymers, Wright–Fisher reproduction, templatedependent misincorporation) shows that replication amplifies the chemistry-built T-skew with a control-corrected gain of only ≈ 1.06×; without mutation the population freezes as a clone at 0.39 pop T/(U+T), and without replication the population goes extinct in 10/10 seeds. The reported optimum is a horizon-edge value: enrichment is still rising at 240 h (3.46×) and continues to 10.2× at 10,000 h while survival decays to 0.32; we therefore report the control-corrected metric, not the absolute CSI, as the headline. All 110 parameters carry explicit provenance (47 literature, 44 assumed, 15 imposed, 3 derived, 1 extrapolated), and the framework closes mass balance to a maximum relative error of 5.7 × 10-15 across a 572-cell sensitivity grid with exactly zero consumedidentity residuals.
Source: ChemRxiv
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235861412
Cites: 16
Cited by:
Related to: 10