Tinjauan Kritis Model Lima Kekuatan Porter untuk Teknologi Additive Manufacturing: Perspektif Ekonomi Industri dan Metodologi Penelitian
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study presents a critical review of the article by Soraya Dias, Pedro Espadinha-Cruz, and Florinda Matos (2023) entitled "A Porter’s Five Forces Model Proposal for Additive Manufacturing Technology: A Case Study in Portuguese industry" in Procedia Computer Science (Vol. 217, pp. 165–176). Evaluated through research methodology and industrial organization economics, this review examines the validity and economic logic of adapting Porter’s Five Forces to Additive Manufacturing (AM) across 13 Portuguese firms. Methodologically, the study exhibits a mismatch between its claimed qualitative exploratory case study design and its execution as a descriptive web survey without thematic coding or inferential testing. Severe selection bias arises because 12 of 13 firms use AM only as an auxiliary prototyping tool (61% report zero final-product weight), alongside contradictions between tables and text (notably the 92% AM knowledge access figure in Table 5 and cross-table misreferencing). Economically, the authors conflate a production process technology with a distinct market boundary, overlooking marginal cost trade-offs between economies of scale and scope, oligopolistic supplier concentration versus low switching costs, labor market friction, and public-good externalities in unprotected intellectual property rights (IPR).
DOI: 10.63822/m6np3d69
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7235862684
