Work

Does Graph-Augmented Retrieval Help on a Small Regulatory Corpus? A Controlled Comparison with Whole-Corpus Prompting

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: On a 12-document aerospace corpus, a graph-augmented retrieval pipeline did not answer or attribute better than vector-only retrieval or than putting the whole corpus in the prompt. We compared four configurations on a 34-question golden set, 3 runs each, from a clean commit, with one shared citation rule: every answer cites documents in a fixed tag format, and citations are scored only on canonical document ids. The full pipeline had the highest golden pass rate (0.824 vs 0.667–0.745), but no paired difference was significant after Holm correction. It brought far more documents into context (context citation recall 0.985 vs 0.763–0.783, significant), yet its answers did not cite more accurately: answer citation F1 was 0.709, against 0.767 for vector-only. Whole-corpus prompting answered best on content (0.922 pass with citation checks excluded) and had the highest answer citation recall, but the lowest RAGAS faithfulness (0.803, significantly below the full pipeline). At this scale, the extra retrieval machinery widens the context without improving what the model writes.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235864746
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10