Work

How Religious Leaders Become Nonbelievers: A Four-Stage Model of Deconversion

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article introduces a four-stage model of clergy deconversion (ontological secularization) based on grounded theory analysis of The Clergy Project, a global community of religious professionals who have lost their faith in the supernatural. Drawing on 59 in-depth interviews and surveys with clergy from 24 countries and multiple religious traditions, along with analysis of more than 300 autobiographical profiles, the study employs a netnographic approach combined with grounded theory to examine how deeply committed practitioners transition from a supernatural to a naturalistic worldview. The model identifies four stages in this trajectory: (1) Accumulation of Doubts — initial questions and contradictions generating cognitive dissonance; (2) Critical Trigger — a pivotal moment that deepens confrontation with doubt; (3) Internal Analysis — critical reflection and the progressive transfer of epistemic authority from religious tradition to personal inquiry; and (4) Acceptance of Nonbelief — a resolution shaped by social and cultural constraints. Central to the model is the concept of epistemic secularization: a structural transformation in how individuals evaluate religious truth-claims. By emphasizing how rather than why clergy reject supernatural belief, and by moving from a categorical to a staged account of this process, this study extends existing theories of religious change and advances understanding of ontological secularization as a structured, epistemologically driven transformation.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $490
OpenAlex ID: W7235910137
FWCI:
Cites: 32
Cited by:
Related to: 10