Work

Was Jesus Caesar?

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: A Bold Intellectual Moment In 2002, Dutch philosopher and public intellectual Paul Cliteur brought Francesco Carotta’s striking theory to a wide national audience. In his column for the respected current-affairs programme Buitenhof, Cliteur presented Carotta’s idea that the figure of Jesus in the Gospels could be understood as a transformed cultural memory of Julius Caesar, shaped through centuries of oral transmission, translation, and reinterpretation. Cliteur treated the proposal not as a minor curiosity, but as an idea with the power to reopen fundamental questions about the origins of Christianity and the making of Western cultural history. He described Carotta’s work as a discovery comparable in intellectual significance to those of Darwin and Galileo—one that, in his view, could overturn conventional accounts of civilisation. His endorsement helped generate a lively public debate in the Netherlands, with the theory discussed in television, radio, newspapers, and intellectual magazines. Whatever one’s final judgement on Carotta’s thesis, Cliteur’s intervention showed a willingness to take an unconventional hypothesis seriously and to invite the public to question inherited historical narratives. It remains a memorable example of a prominent thinker using a mainstream platform to champion an audacious, unconventional idea—and to insist that even the most familiar stories of the past deserve fresh scrutiny.
Author: Paul Cliteur
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235922818
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10