ALP-ttbar Toy MC v2.5 — Post-Registration Results: Resolution Deconflation (SENSOR_DISK_Z Separation)
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Post-registration results for the ALP-ttbar Toy MC v2.5 study: Resolution Deconflation via SENSOR_DISK_Z Separation in Displaced Light ALP → e⁺e⁻ in ttbar Events. The v2.4 endcap simulation used a single DISK_Z array (17 band positions) for both conversion generation and resolution assignment, conflating service-band positions with sensor-disk positions. This meant vertices near passive service material received pixel-quality resolution (σ_z = 1.0 mm) instead of strip-quality (σ_z = 3.0 mm). The v2.5 fix introduces a separate SENSOR_DISK_Z array containing only the 9 sensor disk positions [230, 300, 450, 620, 820, 1100, 1500, 1900, 2300] mm, used exclusively for resolution assignment in _measure_endcap(). The full DISK_Z (17 bands) is retained for conversion generation, veto placement, tag formula evaluation, and nearest-disk pull. v2.5.1 bug fix: The initial run contained a Python import-shadowing bug where sys.path.insert(0, ...) placed the v2.2 endcap_sim.py (without SENSOR_DISK_Z) ahead of the v2.5 version. All reported results are from the corrected v2.5.1 run. Key findings:(1) The resolution deconflation has a significant quantitative effect. HV degradation increases by +0.024× (200 MeV) to +0.047× (50 MeV) across all masses, representing a 42–65% correction relative to the v2.4 HV signal. The conflated resolution was partially compensating for the material effect, causing v2.4 to underestimate the true performance cost of service material.(2) 9 of 10 predictions confirmed using the published v2.3 baseline (P10 refuted: |ΔHV| > |ΔTag|, opposite of predicted). If the recomputed baseline is used, 8 of 10 (P7 and P10 refuted).(3) P3 flips from REFUTED in v2.4 to CONFIRMED in v2.5: the tag/HV ratio decreases by 3.1% from the v2.3 baseline, confirming that the conflation was disproportionately boosting the tag formula's discrimination. Mechanism: ΔHV = +0.045 >> ΔTag = +0.007, raising the denominator of Tag/HV.(4) Validation V3 (200 MeV convergence) is refuted: HV = 1.060× and Tag = 1.061× both exceed the 1.05 threshold.(5) ΔHV is remarkably uniform across pseudorapidity η (+0.044 to +0.047), while ΔTag increases sharply with η (+0.007 at η = 2.0 to +0.110 at η = 2.5). Two versions of the v2.5 preregistration README exist: the DOI-registered version (SHA-256: 4f7b5160...) and an earlier draft (SHA-256 beginning e0d40...). The DOI-registered version is the official preregistration referenced throughout. All 5 sanity gates passed. 5 of 6 validations passed (V3 refuted). Companion to preregistration doi:10.5281/zenodo.24329044. Builds on v2.4 preregistration and results (doi:10.5281/zenodo.24296796, doi:10.5281/zenodo.24302619). Motivated by arXiv:2610.38932 (Niedziela, Alimena et al.). ZIP contains 16 files: README.md, simulation code (run_v25.py, endcap_sim.py, mtag_v24.py, coverage.py, mtag_v21.py, mtag_v22.py), results data (v25_results.npy), chart generator (make_charts.py), PDF generator (make_report_pdf_v25_results.py), 5 comparison charts (PNG), and summary PDF. Independent personal toy study. Not affiliated with the authors of arXiv:2610.38932 or arXiv:2306.08686, nor with the CMS, ATLAS, LHCb or ALICE Collaborations or the FCC study.
Author: Paik, Won Shik
Language: English
Subfield: Nuclear and High Energy Physics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235957608
