Chemical Filtering of Thymine over Uracil by Differential Hydrolysis under Dark Alkaline Hydrothermal-Vent Conditions: A Mass-Consistent, Control-Restrained Simulation Framework (UPDSF v6.7.0)
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Thymine's presence in DNA, and its absence in RNA, is one of the oldest puzzles in molecular evolution. The classical explanation — that DNA uses T to avoid the mutational legacy of cytosine deamination to U — presupposes a genetic system already in place and does not explain whether abiotic chemistry could have enriched T relative to U before genetics existed. Photochemical mechanisms have been proposed, since U absorbs more strongly than T at 260 nm, but they apply only at the surface and fail precisely in dark settings such as alkaline hydrothermal vents, which otherwise offer attractive conditions: sustained thermal gradients, mineral surfaces, pH gradients consistent with serpentinization, and widespread support in the origins-of-life literature.The question this work addresses is deliberately narrow and falsifiable:Can differential hydrolysis stability alone, operating in dark alkaline vent conditions, produce a statistically robust enrichment of thymine over uracil in a prebiotic polymer population — and which destruction channels carry the effect?We answer this with UPDSF v6.7.0, a unified framework that couples (i) a homopolymer reaction–transport engine with explicit free-pool, clay-bound, lipid-compartment, and polymer-residue sub-pools; (ii) a pre-registered battery of decisive controls; and (iii) a new opt-in sequence-resolved engine (v6.7.0) that adds the minimal Darwinian components — heredity, variation, differential reproductive success — absent from the homopolymer abstraction. The framework is built around three commitments: mass consistency (every destroyed residue is accounted for), kinetic consistency (all rates derive from Arrhenius laws with explicitly cited or flagged parameters), and provenance tracking (every parameter is labeled literature / assumed / imposed / derived / extrapolated, with citation).
Author: Reza Hashemi
Language: English
Subfield: Astronomy and Astrophysics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236007824
