Quantitative Evaluation of U.S. State-Level Emergency Operation Plans Using the PMC Index Model
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Emergency Operations Plans (EOPs) are a cornerstone of emergency management at the state level in the United States. However, existing literature has rarely offered a systematic exploration of their content and structure. This study analyzes 39 state-level EOPs using the Policy Modeling Consistency (PMC) index model to evaluate their overall quality. The quantitative results are as follows: (1) PMC scores range from 4.52 to 8.36, with an average of 6.94; among them, 5 EOPs are rated as “Perfect consistency”, 29 as “Excellent consistency”, and 5 as “Acceptable consistency”. (2) The analysis reveals common strengths and recurring weaknesses across states. Most EOPs perform well in Direction, Control, and Coordination (X5), Purpose, Scope, Situation Overview and Planning Assumptions (X2), and Plan Development and Maintenance (X9), while weaknesses are concentrated in Information Collection, Analysis and Dissemination (X6), and Communication and Coordination (X7). (3) High-performing EOPs, such as those from California, Idaho, and Mississippi, demonstrate advanced planning concepts and well-structured, standardized content, offering valuable insights for future improvement. Overall, the study highlights the variation of EOPs and suggests that improving their effectiveness requires three strategies: (1) Strengthen state-level capacity; (2) Enhance information and communication systems; (3) Ensure sustainable plan maintenance and development.
Authors: Peiyang Xu, Mingjing Xu
Institution: Beihang University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,712
OpenAlex ID: W7236044120
