Work

HASSE Ladder G: Pointed Sets, Non-Abelian H1 The Boundary of the Multiplicative-Closure Criterion

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: For non-abelian coefficients the four standard pieces of the abelian H1 template—(a) Z1 is a group, (b) B1 is a subgroup, (c) H1 = Z1/B1 is a quotient group, and(d) the long exact sequence computes kernels and images — fail, but not all at once.We show that the boundary of this failure is cut out by a single explicit criterionC1: Z1 is closed under pointwise multiplication if and only if ρ(g)(Πh) ⊆ CA(Πg)for all g,h ∈ G, where Πg is the image of the g-coordinate inside Z1. The proof usesonly cancellation and the bijectivity of ρ(g), not the commutativity of A, so thecondition is necessary and sufficient. Closure is independent of both the cyclicityof G and the triviality of ρ; the sole determinant is C1 itself. Once C1 is proved(Theorem 5.1), Note 5.1 supplies the finite argument that makes “Z1 is closed”,“Z1 is a group” and “C1 holds” equivalent, so the failure boundary of piece (a) iscompletely characterized by C1. We have B1 ⊆ Z1 unconditionally for every coefficient group; B1 has a sufficient condition for its own closure (ρ(G)(A) ⊆ Z(A)) anda necessary one (C1(B1)), while a full criterion remains open and is registered asOpen Registration 9.3. The twisted-action–lifting correspondence (Theorem 4.1) iscontrolled by the center Z(A): when Z(A) = 1, Φ is a bijection; when Z(A) ̸ = 1the fibers are cosets of Z1(G,Z(A)) and the obstruction lies in H2(G,Z(A)). Thedecision template costs O(|A||S|(|G|2 + |A||G|) + |G|2|A|2) with |S| ≤ log2 |G| —polynomial in |G|, exponential in |A|, hence quasi-polynomial rather than polynomial. On the boundary, injectivity of res fails for non-abelian coefficients (witnessG=A=S3, N =A3, |H1(G,A)| = 3 but |H1(N,A)| = 2), while exactness in thepointed-set sense still holds; there is no contradiction. The paper partially closesone gap registered three times in the series (papers A, C, E), with the residuerecorded chapter by chapter in Chapters 8 and 9.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236059400
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 9