Blue Justice for Small‐Scale Fishers in South Africa: Shifting From Co‐Management to Co‐Governance
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article critically examines the impact of the Policy for the Small Scale Fisheries Sector in South Africa on small‐scale fishers (SSFs). It centres SSFs’ lived experiences, structural barriers to participation, and opportunities for more just and sustainable ocean governance. By recognising small‐scale fisheries as relational systems embedded in community, place, and tradition, the article challenges narrow economistic framings prevalent in dominant blue economy discourses. Despite the progressive aims of the Policy to redress historical marginalisation, integrate SSFs into the formal economy, and promote co‐management, many fishers remain excluded from decision‐making processes, legal recognition, and access to marine living systems. Drawing on in‐depth interviews with SSFs over a two‐year period and a comprehensive literature and legal review informed by legal pluralism and blue justice scholarship, the article demonstrates how persistent governance challenges undermine SSF livelihoods, food security, and cultural identities. These challenges include exclusion from marine protected areas, marginalisation within marine spatial planning processes, and limited recognition within blue economy initiatives. The authors call for a shift away from tokenistic forms of co‐management toward community‐based co‐governance arrangements that recognise customary fishing rights, embed Ubuntu principles, and advance redistributive justice. We argue that integrating restorative justice and Indigenous governance systems into statutory frameworks is essential for achieving blue justice, equity, sustainability, and long‐term resilience in South Africa’s small‐scale fisheries sector.
Source: Ocean and Society
DOI: 10.17645/oas.12592
Institutions: Nelson Mandela University, University of Cape Town
Language: English
Subfield: Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: small-scale fisheries, blue justice, co-governance, co-management, South Africa, blue economy, legal pluralism, customary fishing rights, Ubuntu, restorative justice, Indigenous governance, marine spatial planning, marine protected areas, food security, cultural identity, ocean governance, fisher participation
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236060805
