Work

Durkheim, Parsons, and the Sociology of Belonging: Social Integration, Systemic Reproduction, Imperfect Belonging, and Institutional Adaptability

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This article develops a systematic comparison between Émile Durkheim’s theory of social integration, Talcott Parsons’s theory of social systems, and the Sociology of Belonging. The central question is whether social integration and systemic reproduction, while indispensable to collective life, can become obstacles to social adaptability when established institutional arrangements suppress individual differentiation, criticism, creativity, and innovation. The article begins by presenting the evolutionary, philosophical, psychological, and institutional foundations of the Sociology of Belonging. It then examines Durkheim’s contributions to solidarity, collective representations, moral regulation, and the division of labor, followed by Parsons’s explanation of normative integration, functional differentiation, and systemic reproduction. The comparative analysis identifies substantial theoretical continuities while examining the distinctive contributions of imperfect belonging, dual temporality, and the interaction among economic, integrative, and power systems. The article compares the three theoretical frameworks in their treatment of twelve fundamental sociological problems and evaluates their coverage of twenty theoretical dimensions. Under the criteria of the comparative matrix, Durkheim addresses eight dimensions, Parsons sixteen, and the Sociology of Belonging twenty. These assessments concern theoretical coverage rather than demonstrated scientific superiority. The principal argument is that integration and institutional reproduction can facilitate collective adaptation when they coordinate differentiated participation, but may obstruct adaptation when institutionalized conformity restricts criticism, experimentation, and institutional revision. The article develops a conditional causal explanation of this relationship and identifies empirical expectations concerning institutional openness, social learning, and adaptability. Its contribution is to connect classical theories of social integration and systems with a relational, evolutionary, and nonteleological explanation of institutional reproduction and transformation.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236063873
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10