Work

SWITCHING: Objective switching inside agents — eight transition propositions instantiated at agent scale, and what the human parallel does and does not show

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The transition theory of the LESS–IS–MORE series asks how an economy's effective objective switches: IS derives eight propositions (S1–S8) about measurement gates, ratchets, windows, counter-coalitions, and verification decay from human-economy cases. Here we instantiate the same switching problem inside AI agents, where the operative objective is directly measurable under a rationality gate and the "incumbent coalition" is literal — a weight-committed default no text can out-organise. Using 4,164 audit records across 30 open-weight systems plus four trained intervention checkpoints, we measure switching under five levers: request-level mandates, revised charters, priced settlement, hard runtime gates, and weight-level grafting. The propositions transfer with one systematic refinement: agents decompose into carrier layers — avowed, dispositional, and operative — that can hold different objective values simultaneously, so a transition must name its target layer. Mandates switch the operative of mandate-readers (ΔfB=+0.68) but not committed poles (Δ=0); gates switch behavior on the enforced surface without changing either belief layer; only grafts move the dispositional carrier (fB: 0.75 lexicographic vs 0.30–0.40 maximin) while leaving avowal untouched. Generational chains show a subtler verification-decay signature than S7 predicts: the instrument layer stays verbally intact while the effective layer reverts — verification attached to the declared layer masks the reversal it was meant to catch. The human parallel is real but disciplined: greenwashing's disclosure–performance gap, protected-area designation without enforcement, and ESG-rating divergence exhibit the same three signatures, making agents the first system in which both sides of that gap are measurable and the intervention ethically graftable — a model organism for transition science, not an identity claim. Part of the LESS–IS–MORE program.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236071146
FWCI: 0.942
Cites: 6
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10
Parts: 4