“For your eyes only”—a request for information in terms of section 46 of the Tax Administration Act and a bank's duty of secrecy
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This paper examines the scope and limits of section 46 of the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011, with particular emphasis on requests directed at third parties, and more specifically, financial institutions. We analyse the legislative evolution of the concept of “relevant material” and the jurisprudence confirming that the South African Revenue Service’s information-gathering powers, although broad, are not intended to permit blanket fishing expeditions. The requirement of reasonable specificity and the limitation to material held or reasonably required to be held by third parties serve as important safeguards against abuse. The core focus of this contribution lies in its analysis of bank secrecy and the banker-customer relationship. While banks are contractually and ethically bound to maintain customer confidentiality, this duty is not absolute. A valid section 46 request, therefore, overrides bank secrecy. However, we discuss the practical and reputational dilemma banks face when confronted with requests that are vague, overbroad, or of questionable legality. Banks must balance the risk of regulatory sanction for non-compliance against potential reputational harm and loss of customer trust arising from over-disclosure. We suggest practical considerations to guide financial institutions when responding to section 46 requests, advocating a cautious, context-sensitive approach that mitigates legal and reputational risk while recognising the central role of section 46 in SARS’ tax administration framework.
Source: Journal for Juridical Science
Authors: Fanie Van Zyl, Carika Keulder
Institutions: University of Pretoria, University of the Witwatersrand
Language: English
Topic: Legal Issues in South Africa
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236087480
