Weber, Simmel, Mead, and the Sociology of Belonging: The Social Constitution of Individuals, Differentiated Agency, and the Reproduction and Transformation of Society
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This article develops a systematic comparison between the sociological theories of Max Weber, Georg Simmel, and George Herbert Mead and the Sociology of Belonging. Its central question concerns how individuals are constituted through social relationships and how their differentiated agency contributes to the reproduction or transformation of society. Weber explains social action through subjective meaning, interpretive understanding, legitimacy, and institutional organization. Simmel examines the reciprocal interactions through which social forms emerge, emphasizing differentiation, conflict, and the changing relationships between individuals and groups. Mead explains the social constitution of the self through communication, role-taking, symbolic interaction, and the development of reflexive agency. The Sociology of Belonging incorporates these contributions within a broader evolutionary, psychological, philosophical, and institutional framework. Its central proposition is that individuals develop their capacities through relationships of belonging while never becoming identical with the institutional arrangements that constitute their social environment. This imperfect belonging creates persistent possibilities for individual differentiation, alternative interpretations, conflict, creativity, and institutional transformation. The article examines the similarities and fundamental theoretical differences between these approaches. It compares their explanations of twelve fundamental sociological problems and evaluates their coverage of twenty theoretical dimensions. Under the criteria established in the comparative framework, Weber incorporates ten dimensions, Simmel fourteen, Mead fourteen, and the Sociology of Belonging twenty. These assessments concern theoretical coverage rather than demonstrated scientific superiority. The article argues that the social constitution of individuals and their capacity for differentiated action are complementary processes. Individuals reproduce society through their participation in existing conceptual and institutional systems, but their differences also create possibilities for modifying those systems. Whether these possibilities generate institutional transformation depends on mechanisms involving interpretation, communication, resources, power, collective coordination, and institutional openness. The principal contribution is an integrated explanation of how socially constituted individuals can become agents of institutional reproduction and transformation without assuming either complete individual autonomy or institutional determinism. The analysis advances the Sociology of Belonging as a research framework connecting classical theories of social action and interaction with contemporary questions concerning agency, institutional change, and collective adaptability.
Author: Obregon Diaz, Carlos Federico
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: Max Weber, Georg Simmel, George Herbert Mead, social action, interpretive understanding, social differentiation, conflict, perspective taking, symbolic interactionism, reflexive agency, self-constitution, institutional reproduction, institutional change, sense of belonging, institutional openness
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236095607
