The Puggalapaññatti as the Observer-Trajectory, Supramundane Indriya, and Lyapunov Stability Engine of the Octonionic Abhidhamma: Completing the Seven-Book Abhidhamma Piṭaka under Machine Verification
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: ## Abstract With Papers 1–3 of Series 1 and Series 2 Papers `S2-P1`, `S2-P2`, `S2-P3`, `S2-P25`, `S2-P31` (*Yamaka*), `S2-P32` (*Dhātukathā*), and `S2-P33` (*Kathāvatthu*), six of the seven treatises of the Theravāda *Abhidhamma Piṭaka* have been formally mapped and machine-audited. One foundational treatise remained unformalized: **Book IV, the *Puggalapaññatti*** ("Designation of Human Types"), positioned canonically between the positive conservation architecture of the *Dhātukathā* (Book III) and the adversarial refutation calculus of the *Kathāvatthu* (Book V). Under Guardrail 14 (*"from covering lists to completing lived architecture"*) and Guardrail 16 Tier 1 Priority #2 (*Four Stages of Awakening & Operator-vs.-Attractor Distinction*), the *Puggalapaññatti* supplies the canon's exact coarse-grained taxonomy of **observer-stream trajectories**: distinguishing conventional personhood (*sammuti-paññatti*) from the 82 ultimate realities ($\mathcal{U}_{82}$), linking path transitions to the **22 controlling faculties (*bāvīsati indriyāni*)**, and classifying stability regimes along the path from conditioned worldling (*puthujjana*) across the *gotrabhū* threshold to unshakeable liberation (*akuppādhamma*). Applying Guardrail 13 (*The Selective Correspondence Standard*), we filter out the homiletic *Aṅguttara Nikāya* folk-simile chapters (*Pp 2.2–2.6, 2.10*) and formalize the Abhidhamma-dynamical backbone of the *Puggalapaññatti* inside **`epistemic_v4.1_harness`**, establishing six results: - **Theorem P.I (Six-*Paññatti* Quotient Functor, 22-*Indriya* Bijection, and 12/12 Z3–Python Audit of the 7 *Ariya-Puggalas*).** Formalizing the opening *Mātikā* (*Pp 1*: $5\text{ Khandhas}$, $12\text{ Āyatanas}$, $18\text{ Dhātus}$, $4\text{ Sacca}$, $22\text{ Indriyas}$, and *Puggala*) over the `S2-P32` 170-token / 82-*paramattha* universe proves that `puggala` operates strictly as a coarse-grained quotient designation adding **zero** ultimate *paramattha* entities (`puggala_paramattha_leak_count = 0`, $|\mathcal{U}_{82}| = 82$), while excluding *Nibbāna* as a conditioned constituent of the five-*khandha* person (`nibbana_excluded_from_khandha_puggala = true`). Partitioning the **8 noble stages of *Aṭṭhaka* (*Pp 2.8*)** ($4_{\text{magga}} + 4_{\text{phala}} = 8$) across the **3 supramundane *indriyas*** produces an exact **$1 + 6 + 1 = 8$** bijection (*anaññātaññassāmītindriya* $\mapsto 1$, *aññindriya* $\mapsto 6$, *aññātāvindriya* $\mapsto 1$). Evaluating all $3 \times 2 \times 2 = 12$ faculty/absorption/faith combinations in both Z3 SMT and an independent zero-Z3 Python classifier yields **100% agreement (`12/12`)**, realizing all **7 *Ariya-puggalas*** (*Pp 2.1 / Pp 2.9*) and rejecting `3` canonical impossibilities, while `EpistemicProvenanceLedger` enforces `ABSTAIN_UNDERSPECIFIED` when an assertion omits the `sammuti-paññatti` vs. `paramattha` scope. [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Theorem P.II (Layer $-1$ Exact Rational Farkas Certificates for Designation & Threshold Infeasibilities).** `AutonomousDeadlockScout` and the standalone zero-Z3 `IndependentUnsatChecker` certify relative linear infeasibility ($0 \le -1$ under exact Python `Fraction` multipliers) for: (a) *puggala* reification (`PP_QUOTIENT_LEAK_83_DEADLOCK`), (b) simultaneous activation of path-onset *anaññātaññassāmītindriya* and final-fruit *aññātāvindriya* (`PP_SUPRAMUNDANE_INDRIYA_COLLISION_DEADLOCK`), and (c) counting the threshold *gotrabhū* state simultaneously inside conditioned *puthujjana* and the 8-member *Aṭṭhaka* set (`PP_GOTRABHU_ATTHAKA_OVERFLOW_DEADLOCK`), while Filter A rejects unanchored granularity-vs.-brevity preferences (`TRIVIAL_PARETO_COMPROMISE`) in 0 SMT cycles. [Tier M1; Tier B1.]- **Proposition P.III (Morse–Hessian Regimes, Controlled RK4 Stability, and *Udakūpamā* Persistent Homology).** Auditing a canonical 4D reduced observer potential $V(x; \mu_{\text{fetter}}, u_{\text{guard}})$ with `MorseFrustrationAuditor` (matrix-free $O(kD)$ Lanczos matching analytical Hessians to $\le 8.82 \times 10^{-10}$), RK4 gradient-flow integration (`dt = 0.05`, 300 steps), and $\mathbb{Z}_2$ Vietoris–Rips `TopologicalMorseAuditor` quantitatively separates four canonical *Puggalapaññatti* dynamics: 1. ***Puthujjana* conditioned trap (`REGIME_1_POSITIVE_DEFINITE_TRAP`):** $\mu > 0$, $E_+ = 0.166667 > 0$, $\Phi_2 = 13620.9309$, trapping trajectories at $r_* = 1.0$; 2. ***Gotrabhū* separatrix saddle (`REGIME_2_MORSE_SADDLE_RIDGE`):** Exact single unstable mode ($\iota_- = 1$, $\lambda_{\min} = -0.75$, `hessian_match_err = 8.822e-10`, $\Phi_2 = 1.3184 \times 10^9$) at $r_{\text{sep}} = 0.75$; 3. ***Cetanābhabba* / *Anurakkhaṇābhabba* active control vs. *Kuppādhamma* relapse & Saddle-Node Bifurcation $u_{\text{crit}}$:** From perturbed initial state $r(0) = 0.80 > 0.75$, active guarding control ($u_{\text{guard}} = 0.65$) stabilizes trajectories past the separatrix to $r_{\text{final}} = -0.155353$ (negative because $r \in \mathbb{R}$ is a signed displacement tilted by $+u_{\text{guard}} x_0$), whereas dropping control ($u_{\text{guard}} = 0$) drives relapse back into the clinging trap $r_{\text{final}} = 1.0$. Analytically and under RK4, the *puthujjana* minimum annihilates at the saddle-node threshold $u_{\text{crit}} \approx 0.054964$ ($r_{\text{final}} = 0.920182$ at $u = 0.050$ vs. $-0.019136$ at $u = 0.060$); 4. ***Akuppādhamma* / *Asamayavimutta* unconditional basin (`REGIME_0_CERTIFIED_BASIN`):** After *samuccheda-pahāna* ($\mu = 0$), $E_+ = 0.0$, $\Phi_2 = 0.0$, $\lambda_{\min} = 1.0$, and large perturbations ($\|x(0)\| \approx 1.27$) decay monotonically under **$u_{\text{guard}} = 0$** (`||x_final|| = 3.5e-07`, `lyapunov_monotone_decay = true`). In parallel, `TopologicalMorseAuditor` distinguishes *Sattaka Udakūpamā* (*Pp 2.7*) Type #2 cyclic immersion–resurfacing (`TOPOLOGICAL_INVARIANT_LOOP_CERTIFIED`, $\max\text{pers}(\beta_1) = 0.510152$) from Type #7 dry-shore arrival (`ACYCLIC_OR_POISONED_SINK`, $\max\text{pers}(\beta_1) = 0.0$). [Tier M3; Tier B1/B3.]- **Theorem P.IV (Layer 2b Multi-Span Colimit Gates 1–5 & Guardrail 13 *Aṅguttara* Simile Rejection).** Fusing `Matika_Six_Pannatti_Domain`, `Indriya_Stage_Bijection_Domain`, and `Fetter_Stability_Domain` passes all 5 `PostPushoutVerifier` gates: pre-pinned offline `ChallengeAxiomLock` SHA-256 (`8e4162e185b81709...`), AST replay, $3/3$ Farkas mutation kills (`KS-PP-1..3`), `assumed_count = 0`, `net_free_dof = 0`, and $\Phi_{\text{syn}} = 1.0$. Appending an uncoupled `Anguttara_Cloud_Simile_Slot` (*Pp 2.4*) is rejected fail-closed by Gate 5 ($\Phi_{\text{syn}} = 0.0$), certifying Guardrail 13's boundary inside code. [Tier M2; Tier B2.]- **Theorem P.V (Layer 6 10-Var SAT Manifold & Four Zero-Z3 DPLL + Resolution Refutations).** A 22-clause 10-variable CNF over path/faculty/stability predicates yields exactly **9** canonical profiles matching exhaustive $2^{10} = 1024$ enumeration ($2_{\text{puthujjana}} + 1_{\text{gotrabhū}} + 4_{\text{sekha}} + 2_{\text{akuppādhamma}} = 9$), plus four standalone zero-Z3 `IndependentUnsatChecker` DPLL Resolution Refutations (`VALID_RESOLUTION_REFUTATION`). [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Proposition P.VI (Active Rule Discovery of Serene *Jhāna* Equivalence vs. Diagnostic Boundary Probes).** Under serene unperturbed observation (`P_SERENE_JHANA_OBS`), `ActiveRuleDiscoverer` proves that *akuppādhamma*, *samayavimutta*, *puthujjana* mundane *jhāna*, and eternalist hypotheses produce identical macroscopic observables (`AMBIGUOUS_HYPOTHESIS_CLASS`), whereas permitting control-drop perturbation and supramundane *indriya* / *khandha* probes isolates `H1_CANONICAL_AKUPPADHAMMA` in **2 queries**. [Tier M2; Tier B3.]
Author: Oo, Myo
Language: English
Topic: Indian and Buddhist Studies
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236132006
