Work

A drafting error in the general rules of the H* preregistration (10.5281/zenodo.23268889), and how results will be reported

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: A dated note on the H* preregistration 10.5281/zenodo.23268889 (deposited 9 October 2026), which it does not modify. The drafting error. Under "General rules" the registration states "A ΛCDM-consistent measurement refutes it", without a threshold and without defining "ΛCDM-consistent". The sentence was carried over from the author's earlier registration 10.5281/zenodo.22972538 (created 30 September 2026), where it summarises one outcome of a symmetric distance criterion that "depends only on the distance from the prediction ... and not on whether λ̂ differs from zero": a measurement that lands on ΛCDM and thereby excludes the prediction counts against it. In the H* registration it was copied without that context. Both registered files were checked against the public records (SHA-256 given in the note). Outcome recorded for arXiv:2611.11587 (w0 = −0.883 ± 0.091, wa = −0.48 +0.47/−0.41; values checked against the source). Criterion A: passed (Δχ² = 0.33–0.51 from the registered point). The result is non-discriminating: ΛCDM lies at Δχ² = 1.65–3.02, and a measurement of this precision would pass criterion A with probability 0.87–0.91 if ΛCDM were true. It is counted neither for nor against the model. Read as a standalone rule with criterion A's threshold, the general rule would record this result as "refuted"; it would do so with probability 0.87–0.91 even if the model were exactly true, so that reading is not applied. Reporting from now on (stated after this one result and before any further result): every result is reported with its distance from the prediction and from ΛCDM; a result leaving both within Δχ² = 6.18 is non-discriminating and carries no weight in either direction; criteria A–C and their thresholds are unchanged. Files: the note (PDF, Markdown); hstar_note_2611.11587.py (numpy only) and its output. Use of AI: Claude (Anthropic) assisted with the checks, computations and drafting; the author is responsible for every statement.
Author: Teker, Onur
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236148479
FWCI: 0.619
Cites: 1
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10