Work

Does Football Travel? Estimating How Club Strength Translates Across Europe's Big Five Leagues.

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: How should we compare football clubs competing in different domestic leagues? A club's league position tells us where it stands relative to its own opponents, but not necessarily how that level would translate to a different competition. This paper investigates how club strength translates across Europe's Big Five leagues using 582 club-seasons from the Premier League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga and Ligue 1 between 2020/21 and 2025/26. The analysis combines Club Elo ratings with eight measures of playing characteristics, including possession, pressing, attacking volume, progression and chance quality. Principal component analysis is used to summarise these characteristics, while a leave-one-league-out validation framework tests whether the statistical relationships generalise across competitions. Three principal findings emerge: The Premier League's strength advantage is broad. Its Club Elo advantage is visible across much of the strength distribution rather than being confined to the strongest clubs or the bottom half. The same club level can occupy very different positions across leagues. Brighton & Hove Albion provide a worked example. Their 2025/26 modelled level sits around eighth-equivalent in the Premier League but third-equivalent in Serie A under the main simulation assumptions. Playing characteristics explain more than they forecast. Adding same-season tactical information reduces held-out-league mean absolute prediction error by 9.8%. However, previous-season playing characteristics do not improve next-season predictions beyond entering-season Club Elo. The cross-league comparisons are controlled statistical counterfactuals, not forecasts of actual club relocations. The paper includes model validation, uncertainty diagnostics, sensitivity analyses and a discussion of the limitations of comparing clubs across different competitive environments.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236170967
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10