Work

Mortgage Application Outcomes: Theory of AI Assistance and HMDA Measurement Sensitivity

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: AI assistance can change mortgage application incentives and the composition of borrowers reaching a credit decision. We develop a lender-choice and documentation-continuation model with general differentiable documentation and perceived-cost functions. The framework admits privacy concerns and trust improvements, distinguishes participation and funded-volume thresholds, and shows how conditional approval can move in either direction under fixed underwriting. Public HMDA records provide a descriptive application to decision measurement. At a common application mix, Better Mortgage’s 2024–2025 purchase change relative to 30 comparison institutions combines higher recorded administrative resolution and funded conversion with lower conditional approval. Documentation completion and borrower-level AI exposure remain latent. Across 33 selected reporting entities, seven purchase comparisons change sign under a common denominator-classification fraction. Using five- and ten-percentage-point classification-spread benchmarks, chosen for sensitivity rather than calibrated to observed practice, makes 11 and 13 documentation-only comparisons direction-ambiguous. Better’s 32-peer comparison ranges from −3.80 to +5.82 percentage points at the classification endpoints. These are sharp measurement ranges conditional on declared restrictions rather than estimates of the correct latent classification or AI effects. The contribution combines general selection mechanisms with transparent measurement sensitivity in recorded lending outcomes.
Source: FinTech
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,207
OpenAlex ID: W7236178351
FWCI:
Cites: 13
Cited by:
Related to: 10