Witnessing under Constraint: Mary Louise Graffam, the Armenian Genocide, and the Production of Historical Testimony, 1915–1919
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article re-examines the testimony of Mary Louise Graffam, an American missionary educator based in Sivas during the Armenian Genocide. It asks not simply what Graffam witnessed, but how her testimony was produced, transmitted, and subsequently interpreted. The article argues that her account is best understood as a layered documentary record shaped by her institutional position, the limits placed on her movement and communication, and the temporal distance between wartime reporting and retrospective recollection. It challenges claims that women missionaries necessarily possessed privileged access to Armenian women's experiences, while showing how gender, nationality, professional role, and missionary affiliation together conditioned the circumstances of observation. Through a critical reading of Susan Billington Harper's published reconstruction of Graffam's reports, alongside scholarship on gender, missionary relief, and historical testimony, the article distinguishes direct observation from reported information and later interpretation. It proposes that Graffam's significance lies not in an unmediated or uniquely authoritative voice, but in the documentary trajectory of her testimony and the questions it raises about evidence, witnessing, and humanitarian knowledge.
Author: Dadvar, Sara
Language: English
Subfield: Literature and Literary Theory
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Gender equality
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236194675
