SAE Propagation of Cultivation Paper 4: The Propagation of Cultivation: A Link / SAE 涵育的传播 Paper 4: 涵育的传播:一环
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper reads how cultivation passes downstream by one link. A person who is willing to receive, whose own judgment opens up, and who then goes on to cultivate another person is a link in the chain along which cultivation propagates. All three rest with the person in the middle: whether he is willing to receive, whether his judgment opens up, whether he goes on to give and, in giving, whether he takes over the step that is the other's to take. They are not the three things a giver looks at in assessing, which are whether the other is willing, whether he is suited, and whether the time is ripe. Being willing to receive is not taking everything as given: the receiver can disagree, can change it, can take only part. The opening of judgment is read by the definition of judgment; doing as told, or arriving at the same conclusion, does not prove it. Giving is reckoned up to "carried out": he took on the direction of cultivation, and his act actually opened conditions for another person; whether that person becomes the next link is read separately. A single act can carry both directions, recorded separately and not netted out. Giving is also practice: to give to someone, one has to judge where he is stuck and how far to give. Giving onward is not a debt: having received, one does not thereby owe anyone. For a person standing in the 15DD direction, cultivation is inwardly his own cannot-not, and toward the other a direction; whether to give this time is first assessed against conditions. Where he did not give and the judgment, looked back on, was wrong, or where he judged that this was his to give, the judgment still stood, and he did not give, it is recorded as failing to do his part; that entry comes from his own judgment, not from having received. Each link has a separate account of time and effort, which this end's gain is not used to offset. The paper uses two pieces of writing as historical material, Lu Xun on his teacher Fujino and Xiao Hong on Lu Xun, and stops where the material stops. It does not show that a person who received cultivation will give onward, does not say he ought to, does not show that giving makes the other's judgment open up, and does not rate anyone's way of training people. 这一篇读涵育这一边怎样往下一环。一个人肯受,自己的判断长开了,再去涵育另一个人,是涵育传播链上的一环。这三件都在中间那个人自己:肯不肯受,长不长开,去不去给、给的时候替不替。它们不是给的人评估时要看的那三样;那三样是愿不愿意、适不适合、时机成没成。 肯受不等于照单全收:受的人可以不同意,可以改,可以只取一部分。长开照判断力的定义读;照做、结论一致,不证明这一件已经成了。去给,算到「做出了」为止:他承担了涵育的方向,他的作为也实际打开了另一个人的条件;后一个人接不接成下一环,另读。同一次作为可以两向都有,分开记,不合成净值。去给也是练:给一个人,要判断他卡在哪里,给到哪一步为止。 往下给不是债:受过,不因此欠着谁。站在 15DD 方向上的人,涵育对内是他自己的不得不,朝对方是方向;这一次给不给,先评估条件。没有给而回看是判错了的,或判了由自己给、这一判还在却没有给的,记没做到;这一笔由他自己的那一判来,不由受过来。每一环另有一本时间与心力的账,不拿这一端的所得去抵。 这一篇用鲁迅写藤野、萧红写鲁迅的两段文字作史料,读到哪里停在哪里。它不证明受过涵育的人会往下给,不说他应当往下给,不证明给了对方就会长开,也不评谁带人带得好。
Author: Qin, Han
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236197632
