Work

Conventional versus digitally assisted training and assessment of ceramic onlay preparations in preclinical dentistry: a quasi-experimental cohort study

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Digital preparation analysis is increasingly used in preclinical dental training and examinations. Whether established scoring frameworks yield comparable results with conventional and digitally assisted assessment remains uncertain. METHODS: This quasi-experimental study compared two consecutive cohorts completing a standardised ceramic onlay preparation examination. The conventional cohort (n = 31) received conventional training and visual-tactile assessment, including a silicone index. The digitally assisted cohort (n = 32) had voluntary access to digital self-assessment during training, and final preparations were assessed using three-dimensional scans and preparation analysis software. Both cohorts used the same 15 weighted criteria (maximum 42 points), passing threshold (29 points), and critical-failure rules. For occlusal reduction, the target range was 1.0-1.5 mm; digital assessment permitted 0.9-1.6 mm, with any identified local measurement outside this range resulting in failure of that criterion. The primary outcome was the official examination score; secondary outcomes included individual criteria, pass rates, and academic motivation. RESULTS: Median scores were 30.0 points conventionally and 25.5 points digitally (Mann-Whitney U test, p = 0.035). The mean difference (digital minus conventional) was - 3.88 points (95% CI - 7.38 to - 0.37). The occlusal-reduction criterion was recorded as met in 22/31 conventional preparations (71.0%) but 0/32 digitally assessed preparations (Holm-adjusted p < 0.001), contributing - 2.84 points to the mean score difference. Excluding this criterion reduced the mean difference to - 1.04 points (95% CI - 4.42 to 2.35). Uniform shoulder width was less frequently recorded as achieved digitally (17/32 versus 29/31; Holm-adjusted p = 0.006), and adjacent-tooth damage was recorded more frequently (16/32 versus 7/31; p = 0.036). Pass rates were 51.6% conventionally and 25.0% digitally. No statistically detectable differences in academic motivation were observed. CONCLUSIONS: Lower observed scores in the digitally assisted cohort were concentrated in a criterion assessed using a different measurement procedure and tolerance rule. Because training and assessment methods changed simultaneously, differences in student performance cannot be separated from differences arising from the assessment procedures. Comparability should be evaluated before existing scoring frameworks are applied to digital practical examinations. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Not applicable.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,990
OpenAlex ID: W7236209819
FWCI:
Cites: 30
Cited by:
Related to: 10
Parts: 2