An Empirical Model for the Relative Compressive Strength of Concrete Containing Rice Husk Ash, Palm Oil Fuel Ash and Sugarcane Bagasse Ash
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Rice husk ash (RHA), palm oil fuel ash (POFA) and sugarcane bagasse ash (SCBA) are abundant agro-industrial residues that can partially replace Portland cement in concrete, but designers lack a simple, validated way to estimate how much strength a given replacement will cost. This study developed and tested a literature-derived empirical model for the strength ratio R, the compressive strength of an ash concrete divided by that of the plain cement concrete made with the same materials in the same laboratory. From a database of 736 records in 37 published experimental programmes, 574 ash-concrete records from 35 programmes were each paired with their own control and used for modelling. Nine candidate models were fitted by least squares with standard errors clustered by programme and tested by leave-one-study-out validation, in which every programme in turn was predicted by a model that had never seen it. The adopted model, ln R = −(5.46 − 3.94g)x² + 0.123x ln(t/28), uses the replacement fraction x (ash mass divided by total binder mass), the curing age t in days and an indicator g that equals 1 when the source study reported milling the ash to standard fineness or beyond, as classified from the processing it described, and 0 otherwise. All three terms were statistically significant. Coding grinding in four ordered levels did not improve predictions, and neither did separate terms for the three ashes (p = 0.74) or loss on ignition. On programmes it had not seen, the model predicted R with a root-mean-square error of 0.166, against 0.205 for a constant median (bootstrap 95% interval of the reduction 0.007 to 0.067), and explained about one-third of the variance in R. The model indicates that unground ash can replace about 9% of the binder for a 5% loss of 28-day strength and that milling raises this to about 18%, or 23% if strength is assessed at 90 days. These are preliminary estimates for an average ash source; the scatter between sources remains large, so trial mixes are still required.
DOI: 10.64388/ire1725277
Authors: Joy T. Ojo, Oluwatosin. P. Akintunde
Institution: University of Ibadan
Language: English
Subfield: Civil and Structural Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7236212114
