Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: In the wake of COVID-19, a heterogeneous set of alternative grading schemes — including specifications grading, mastery-based assessment, and ungrading — have gained significant traction across higher education, often promoted as routes to equity, transparency, and student agency. This article situates these reforms within broader cultural logics of power rather than treating them as merely technical innovations. Drawing on Michel Foucault’s account of disciplinary society and Byung-Chul Han’s critique of the performance society, it argues that many grading reforms reconfigure — rather than dismantle — the imperatives of visibility, legibility, and self-optimization that shape contemporary education. The analysis is supported by philosophical critique, cross-disciplinary empirical and qualitative research on assessment reform, and situated classroom accounts from large introductory chemistry courses at a U.S. public research university. Across these sources, students often welcome the clarity and structure promised by alternative grading, while also reporting heightened anxiety, burnout, and internalized surveillance. Faculty, too, become data producers, increasingly required to perform care, equity, and effectiveness for institutional audits. The article contends that genuine pedagogical transformation requires more than new grading instruments; it requires questioning the assumption that all learning must be rendered visible and auditable in order to count. By foregrounding the unmeasurable dimensions of learning — curiosity, relational trust, ethical judgment — it calls for pedagogical spaces where growth is not continually staged as performance.
Source: Critical education
Parent work: Critical Education, Vol. 17 No. 4 (2026)
Author: Sun, Shuai
Institution: University of Kansas
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: alternative grading, specifications grading, mastery-based assessment, ungrading, disciplinary society, performance society, Michel Foucault, Byung-Chul Han, assessment reform, student anxiety, burnout, school surveillance, institutional audit, pedagogical transformation, general chemistry, student agency, higher education equity
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236226581
