Choosing Models for Agricultural Policy Impact Assessment: A Comparative Review of Frameworks, Trade-Offs and Applications
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Quantitative models are widely used to assess agricultural policy impacts, but their capacity to represent economic, environmental and social sustainability outcomes varies considerably. This paper provides a structured comparative review of 414 studies identified through Scopus and Web of Science, combining descriptive and thematic analysis with an assessment of major agricultural policy modelling frameworks. The review examines publication trends, thematic evolution and sustainability coverage of the field, and compares partial equilibrium, computable general equilibrium, integrated assessment and land-use, bioeconomic and hybrid models in terms of analytical scope, strengths, limitations and policy suitability. The literature has expanded markedly since 2010 and diversified from a strong early focus on agricultural support and trade towards climate, environmental and resource-related questions. Economic outcomes remain dominant: 355 studies address at least one economic dimension, compared with 201 addressing environmental outcomes and 67 addressing explicitly social outcomes; while only 14 cover all three sustainability dimensions. This imbalance indicates that agricultural policy modelling has become increasingly environmentally integrated without achieving comparable integration of social sustainability. The paper relates model capabilities and research gaps to SDGs 2, 6, 8, 12, 13 and 15 and proposes a practical framework for selecting models according to policy mechanisms, sustainability dimensions, spatial and temporal scales, and data requirements. The review therefore contributes to sustainability-oriented policy analysis by clarifying which modelling approaches are most appropriate for assessing multidimensional agricultural policy impacts.
Source: Sustainability
DOI: 10.3390/su182211714
Institutions: Agrárközgazdasági Intézet, Corvinus University of Budapest
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: agricultural policy modelling, model selection, partial equilibrium model, computable general equilibrium model, integrated assessment models, land use models, bioeconomic model, hybrid model, sustainability dimensions, social sustainability, environmental sustainability, economic sustainability, Sustainable Development Goals, research gaps
SDGs: Zero hunger, Climate action
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,896
Award: G9001397350
OpenAlex ID: W7236233851
