Work

Barriers to Implementing Single-Case Experimental Designs for Measurement-Based Care: A Mixed Methods Feasibility Study

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Measurement-based care (MBC) increasingly integrates experience sampling methods (ESM) to support case conceptualization, treatment monitoring, and feedback. Combined with single-case experimental designs (SCED), this allows casual inferences about intervention effects for the individual. However, implementation remains challenging. This study aimed to prepare for the implementation of an ESM based SCED infrastructure in an outpatient university-affiliated psychotherapy setting. We conducted a preregistered mixed-methods feasibility study with adult and adolescent patients, caregivers, and therapists. Across three iterative SCED phases (baseline, diagnostic, intervention), patients and caregivers completed two-week daily time-contingent ESM surveys with optional event-contingent surveys and boosters. Usability, acceptability, adherence, and compliance were assessed via questionnaires and ESM data. Semi-structured interviews explored perceived barriers. Usability and acceptability were generally good, but acceptability varied and tended to decline over time. Adherence fell below the predefined criterion, whereas compliance among adherent participants generally met the criterion, except in adolescents. Perceived burden was low, but perceived helpfulness limited. Interviews revealed distinct barriers: Patients and caregivers mainly reported gaps in reflecting personal experiences, followed by response burden and challenges integrating assessments into daily life. Therapists mainly reported limited resources, limited utility to guide change, and uncertainty in interpreting data. These findings may inform strategies for implementing ESM-based SCED systems in routine care. Future work should focus on enhancing personalization of assessments and addressing limited therapist resources to support clinical integration. A key challenge remains ensuring that the ESM-based SCED infrastructure is perceived not as an administrative burden, but as a tool that meaningfully enhances therapeutic processes.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236249708
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10