Work

A Discussion of Fact Recognition under Manifestational Limits

Year: 2026
Type: report
Abstract: This paper investigates the conditions under which factual claims about occurrences, relational configurations, and generative histories can be recognized through partial manifestations. It distinguishes what obtains in an adopted inquiry domain, propositions concerning it, evidence-bearing traces, procedural standings, and situated judgments. Generative Relational Theory supplies three mutually coupled analytical registers—ontological, relational, and manifestational—while Noetarium’s law-domain categorical schema provides a specific example of the distinction between factual kind, procedural route, and archived trace. The paper develops target-relative observational equivalence, recoverability of factual properties, loss of categorical paths, and the difference between exact identification, finite-sample inference, and resource-bounded verification. It then examines judgments made under different standards, the diagnosticity of AI-mediated and other symbolic representations, and the relational effects of stabilized classifications. Recognitive ethics is developed as an independently justified normative proposal concerning proportionality, correction, and avoidable irreversible harm under finite resources. The final sections specify operational measures and prospective empirical designs, with explicit limits on causal and historical inference. Mathematical results are conditional on stated models; the three-register account is not presented as an exhaustive ontology; and the manuscript reports no original population-level estimate of AI’s effect on fact recognition.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236254596
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10