Work

Utilidade do conhecimento: critério consequencial, credencialismo e a justificação do valor formativo na educação contemporânea

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Objective: To examine under what conditions the demand for usefulness constitutes a legitimate criterion for judging the value of a body of knowledge within education, and to propose a distinction between orders of utility as a differentiated curricular criterion. Literature review: The association between schooling and earnings admits competing explanations that diverge precisely on the point that matters to education, contrasting human capital with accounts centred on signalling, filtering and credentials. The debate conflates three distinct objects under the name of usefulness: the formative usefulness of knowledge, the instrumental usefulness of its application and the positional usefulness of the credential, credentialism being rational in the positional register yet corrosive of formative usefulness. The symmetrical objection is examined, according to which the defence of disinterested formation may operate as indifference to students' material needs, and three orders of knowledge utility are proposed, immediate, deferred and constitutive, discriminated by temporal horizon, transferability and type of transformation produced. Final considerations: The demand for usefulness is legitimate when it makes explicit both its object and the relevant order of contribution. The absence of primary evidence and the concentration of empirical literature in high-income countries are acknowledged as limitations.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7236263516
FWCI:
Cites: 14
Cited by:
Related to: 10