Responsive Cues Converted Into Reciprocal Obligation: When Something That Answers Seems to Be Owed, or to Owe
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This conceptual paper introduces Responsive Cues Converted Into Reciprocal Obligation, a mechanism through which repeated signs of attention can lead someone to feel that care is owed in either direction. A device that comes when called or asks to be held may come to seem like a companion who depends on its owner. The owner, in turn, may expect someone to keep that companion functioning. The mechanism concerns the point at which such an expectation extends beyond any commitment established by the people or institutions behind the device. The paper places this account alongside Byron Reeves and Clifford Nass’s work on how people apply social conventions to computers and other media. It asks what a particular person came to expect, which words or actions connect that expectation to a responsive cue, and who undertook to honor it. A person’s account of companionship can establish what the relationship meant to them. A provider’s statements and policies supply evidence about what that provider promised. Sony’s AIBO illustrates the distinction. Sony offered repairs for its earlier models for stated periods, and its repair clinic operated beyond the latest deadline in its notice. In 2018, owners of the new aibo asked Sony to extend its policy of providing repairs for seven years after withdrawal from sale. The founder of A FUN, an independent repair firm, argued that Sony bore continuing responsibility for the companion it had brought to market. The paper leaves the merits of that demand open. GROOVE X’s LOVOT provides a contrast through priced care plans whose written terms specify what the maker will cover. Part of the Presence Through Technology series within On Human Modeling, the paper also offers a way to examine expectations of discretion in human–AI interaction. A conversational assistant might recall a private concern and ask about it weeks later. If the user explains that being remembered led them to expect the exchange to stay private, that account connects a specific cue to a specific expectation. The provider’s confidentiality commitments can then be compared with what the user understood.
Author: Cary, Alexandra
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7236266640
